How to Make Culture Change Stick

By Joe Newsum

You have done the hard creative work. You have built great commitments, whether core, operating, or activity commitments. Now comes the part where almost everyone fails: getting the whole organization to actually adopt them, until people own the commitments and the culture sustains itself. After doing this many times, I have learned it comes down to concentrating on one domain at a time and then doing three things relentlessly. You drive people to see the commitments, use them, and you reinforce them relentlessly. That is how culture change sticks.

The stakes are real: transformations are 5.3 times more likely to succeed when senior leaders model the changes they ask of everyone else. Most culture efforts have plenty of frameworks, launches, and effort. What they lack is depth: the effort gets spread thin and never reaches the point where behavior actually changes. The framework on this page is built to fix that. Source: McKinsey, The Science of Organizational Transformations.

Most culture change fails because it is spread too thin, broad and shallow across everything at once, so nothing reaches the depth that real adoption requires. The framework here is the opposite: deep and narrow, then driven relentlessly until people genuinely make the commitments their own. Let me walk through all three parts.

How to make culture change stick framework: concentrate on one domain, then see, use, and reinforce the commitments until people own them, powered by six levers

Why Culture Change Is So Hard

Before the framework, it helps to be honest about what you are up against, because most people badly underestimate it. Culture change is a kind of mental guerrilla warfare. Every person you are trying to change arrives carrying thousands of cumulative years of inherited histories, behaviors, educations, and experiences. You are not writing on a blank page. You are trying to overwrite all of that, in hundreds or thousands of people at once, and the old ways do not surrender easily.

You do not win that fight with one big frontal assault. A splashy launch, a values poster, an all-hands, those wash off in weeks. You win it the way guerrilla campaigns are won: with focus, precision, and relentlessness. You concentrate your forces on one piece of ground, you stay on it far longer than feels comfortable, and you do not let up until it is genuinely yours. Then you take the next piece. The framework is exactly that discipline, made practical.

First, Concentrate: Pick One Domain

Before anything else, you decide where to focus. Trying to change the whole culture everywhere at once is the single most common reason culture change fails. Instead, you concentrate on one domain at a time, one area or activity where culture visibly lives, such as how the organization runs its meetings, and you drive the commitments there until the new way becomes self-sustaining. Then you move to the next domain and compound. I call this discipline Threshold Concentration, and it is the foundation everything else sits on.

Concentration is the decision that makes the rest possible. You cannot drive deep adoption everywhere at once, there is not enough leadership attention, communication, or energy to go around. By concentrating on one domain, you give the commitments the focus they need to cross a tipping point and hold on their own. Read the full method behind Threshold Concentration, including the science of why it works.

Then Drive Adoption: See Them, Use Them, Reinforce Them

Once you have concentrated on a domain, adoption comes down to three things, done relentlessly and together. People have to see the commitments and use them, and you have to reinforce them. These are not steps in a sequence, they happen at once and feed on each other. Do all three well enough, in one domain, and people stop complying and start owning the commitments. That is the goal: not behavior you have to keep pushing, but commitments people make their own.

Do those three, and people come to own the commitments. When people see the commitments, use them until they are second nature, and are reinforced from every direction, ownership follows. They hold each other to the commitments without being told, defend them, and pass them to new hires. That is the threshold: the culture now protects itself, and the change no longer needs you to push it. It sustains itself.

Pick a commitment you are trying to drive. Are people seeing it, modeled, working, and upheld? Are they using it until it is second nature? Are you reinforcing it from every direction? Wherever the answer is no is where the work is.

The Engine: The Levers That Drive Adoption

The three actions are what you are driving people to do. The levers are how you do it. There are six of them, and most serve more than one of the three actions, which is why you pull them all at once rather than one at a time. Their power comes from working together. This is where most of the real work lives, and where a lever has its own deep-dive page, the title links to it.

Communication

Make the commitments unmissable. Tell the story of why they matter, repeat the language relentlessly, and weave it into every channel until people cannot avoid hearing it. The full playbook, from launch story to the steady tsunami of small wins, lives on its own page.

Modeling

Leaders visibly live the commitments, every day, in how they run meetings, give feedback, and make decisions. People do what leaders do, not what they say. If leaders do not model it, nothing sticks. Why leadership modeling is the make-or-break lever gets its own deep dive.

Capability

Teach people how to actually do it. Even when people believe in a commitment, they will fall back to old habits if they do not feel capable. Give them the tools, the practice, and the how, so living the commitment is achievable, not just aspirational.

Accountability

Make the standard real by holding people to it, and make it peer-to-peer, where anyone can respectfully call anyone to the commitment, regardless of level. Accountability is what turns a nice idea into a genuine norm. The open accountability model has its own page.

Recognition

Celebrate the commitments being lived, loudly and often. Catch people doing it right and make it visible. Recognition reinforces the behavior and signals to everyone what the culture truly values.

Aligned incentives

Make sure the formal systems point the same way. Performance reviews, promotions, and rewards should all reflect the commitments. When what gets rewarded matches what you are asking for, adoption accelerates. When it does not, people follow the incentives, not the commitments.

The power is in pulling them together. Any one lever alone is weak. Communication without modeling is just talk. Modeling without accountability fades. Incentives without capability frustrate. Research on behavior change consistently finds that using the levers together, rather than one at a time, dramatically raises the odds the change lasts: McKinsey’s work on transformations shows organizations that deploy all the influence actions together are far more likely to succeed than those that use a few. Concentrate them all on one domain and you reach the threshold far faster. Source: McKinsey, The Four Building Blocks of Change.

What It Looks Like When It Works

Here is the framework running in a real engagement, one you will recognize if you have read the meeting culture page, because this is the implementation story behind it.

Driving real adoption is the hardest and most valuable part of culture change, and it is where I spend most of my time with clients. See how Joe works with clients or email him directly at joe@stratechi.com if you want a partner in it.

Putting It Together

The whole framework is simple to hold and hard to do. Concentrate on one domain. Drive people to see the commitments and use them, and reinforce them, pulling every lever at once: communication, modeling, capability, accountability, recognition, and aligned incentives. Get one domain to the point where people own the commitments and it sustains itself, then move to the next and compound. Do that, and culture change stops being the thing that fails and becomes the thing that builds, domain by domain, into a culture that holds on its own.

Every lever matters, but one of them decides the outcome. Read next: Leadership and Culture Change, why modeling from the top is the lever that makes or breaks all the others.

Work with Joe
The value you and your team create = Focus × Speed × Rigor
I help leaders and their teams get better at all three through executive coaching, workshops, and training.
Coach to Fortune 500 CEOs  ·  McKinsey and Oliver Wyman alum  ·  Former CEO, COO, CFO, and CMO
Or get my latest thinking on strategy, leadership, and culture in your inbox. No noise, just the good stuff.